It is possible that the kidnapper was Lorraine Fountain herself. It is possible that she was an intermediary who acquired the infant from someone else. Without evidence that answers the question directly, the possibility space remains open.

 

What remains, in the absence of that answer, is the case as it stands: a kidnapping that created a cascade of consequences across sixty years, resolved in most of its parts by tools that did not exist in 1964, with the central perpetrator still unidentified.

 

 

 

## What It Means to Be Found

 

The man raised as Paul Fronczak was found — in the sense that the 1965 identification used that word — when he was a toddler in New Jersey. He was found again, in a different sense, in 2015, when genetic genealogy established that he was Jack Rosenthal. The actual missing infant, Kevin Baty, was found in 2019. And Jill Rosenthal has not been found.

 

The word found, in this case, carries several distinct meanings that are worth separating.

 

The first finding — Scott McKinley in the Newark stroller — was a physical location. A child was present in a public space, identified as abandoned, taken into state care, and eventually identified conditionally as the missing Paul Fronczak. The finding was geographical: the child was located.

 

The second finding — Jack Rosenthal — was an identity revelation. The man raised as Paul Fronczak was located all along; he was findable at any address he had ever held, any phone number he had ever registered. What was found was not his location but his name and his biological history. This finding was produced by science applied to genetics.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.