The documentary record also serves a function for the family. The man raised as Paul Fronczak has been generous in his public engagement with the case, participating in extensive media coverage over more than a decade. His willingness to discuss the case publicly — to describe his experience of the DNA revelation, to describe what it meant to learn he was Jack Rosenthal, to describe the ongoing search for Jill — has created a record that will outlast him and that his daughter and other family members will have access to.

 

The documentary record does not resolve the case’s unresolved questions. But it preserves them in a form that future investigators, future genealogists, and future family members can work from. The case of Jack and Jill Rosenthal, the case of the 1964 kidnapper, the case of Lorraine Fountain’s role — these questions will be accessible in the future because of the sustained public documentation the case has generated.

 

## A Case That Is Not Over

 

The Paul Fronczak case is frequently described, in media shorthand, as the story of a man who learned he was someone else. That description captures something true but understates the complexity of what the case actually is.

 

It is the story of an infant taken from a hospital in 1964 and raised under a different name until his death in 2020. It is the story of a family that accepted a stranger’s child as their missing son and raised him in love for half a century. It is the story of a toddler abandoned in a stroller in Newark, New Jersey, who became a man with a wife and a daughter and a career and a name. It is the story of a twin sister who has not been found. It is the story of a kidnapper who has not been identified. It is the story of a technology — genetic genealogy — that resolved questions that had been unanswerable for fifty years and continues to develop in ways that may eventually answer the questions that remain.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.