The resolution the case achieved is genuine but incomplete. Two of its three primary mysteries have been answered: the man raised as Paul Fronczak was identified as Jack Rosenthal, and the infant taken from Michael Reese Hospital was identified as Kevin Baty. The third mystery — what happened to Jill Rosenthal — remains open. The subordinate mysteries — who took Paul Fronczak, what role Lorraine Fountain played, what exactly happened in the Rosenthal household — are partly answered, partly not.

 

This is the condition of many investigations: not clean resolution but partial illumination, with the light reaching far enough to change the fundamental character of the darkness but not far enough to illuminate everything. The Paul Fronczak case is unusual in the degree to which it has been illuminated — the degree to which the investigative tools of a later era were able to answer questions that the investigative tools of the original era could not. But it shares with most cold cases the experience of ending not with a closed door but with an open one, through which some light falls, and beyond which some questions remain.

 

The man identified as Jack Rosenthal continues to look for his sister. The FBI continues to investigate. The NCMEC continues to publish Jill’s age-progressed composite. The genetic databases continue to grow.

 

The case is not over. It is at rest, the way most cold cases are at rest — with the available tools applied, the available evidence interpreted, the available answers given, and the remaining questions waiting for the tool or the witness or the database entry that has not yet arrived.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.