## The Child Who Was Not There

 

One of the strangest aspects of the Paul Fronczak case, considered from a certain angle, is the specific absence at its center.

 

For forty-seven years, from approximately 1967 to 2012, the case of the missing infant Paul Joseph Fronczak was considered solved. The FBI’s file was not closed — cold cases are rarely formally closed in the United States — but the working assumption of everyone involved, including the FBI and the Fronczak family, was that the case had been resolved with the identification of the Newark toddler. Paul had been found. The family was whole.

 

This assumption was wrong. And the wrongness of the assumption had a specific character: it was not simply that the wrong child had been identified. It was that the right child — the actual missing infant — had been simultaneously invisible as a missing person and visible as a person in the world. Kevin Baty existed throughout those forty-seven years. He had a childhood, a life, a family. He was not hiding. He was simply not known, by the people looking for him, to be the person they were looking for.

 

This is a genuinely unusual feature of the case. Most cases in which a missing person is eventually found after a long period of absence involve the missing person having been in some state of genuine absence — unable to be located, hidden, unidentifiable, or dead. Kevin Baty was none of these. He was present, in Michigan, living an ordinary life under the name he had been given, without knowing (or apparently without publicly stating that he knew) that his biological origins were as extraordinary as they turned out to be.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.