The DNA test that identified him was the event that made his visibility complete — that connected the person he was to the case that had been looking for him for fifty-five years. Before that test, he was invisible to the investigation not because he was absent but because the investigation had no way to see him as the person it was looking for.

 

## The Ethical Inheritance

 

The Paul Fronczak case leaves a set of ethical questions that have no clean answers — questions about consent, about the right to know, about the obligations of the living to the missing, about the claims of biological origin against the claims of lived experience.

 

The consent question centers on the DNA test of 2012. Chester and Dora Fronczak initially consented to the test and then withdrew their consent before the results were processed. Their son submitted the test anyway, without their consent. This was legal. Whether it was right — whether his right to know his own genetic origins outweighed their interest in not having the settled narrative of their family disrupted — is a genuine ethical question on which reasonable people can disagree.

 

The right-to-know question runs in multiple directions. The man raised as Paul Fronczak had an interest in knowing whether the story he had been given about his origins was accurate. Chester and Dora had an interest in not having a fifty-year family narrative challenged by a laboratory result. The actual Paul Fronczak — Kevin Baty — had an interest in knowing (whether or not he exercised it) that his biological identity was different from the one he lived under. Jill Rosenthal, wherever she is, has an interest in knowing (whether or not she can access it) that she has a twin brother who is looking for her.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.