These interests conflict in various ways, and the case did not resolve the conflicts so much as it navigated them: the DNA test happened; the results became known; the investigation proceeded; the families adjusted as best they could. The ethical questions remain live, in the sense that the case offers no principle by which to rank the competing interests against each other.

 

What the case does offer is an example of how such conflicts can be navigated — not cleanly, not without pain, but in a way that ultimately moved toward more truth rather than less. The man raised as Paul Fronczak chose to pursue the question of his origins over his parents’ objections, and the result was a case that resolved more of its mysteries than any reasonable expectation in 2012 would have justified. Chester and Dora Fronczak, despite the initial period of estrangement, eventually reconciled with their son and participated in the documentation of the case. Kevin Baty had a phone call with Dora Fronczak before he died.

 

None of these outcomes was guaranteed by the DNA test. All of them followed from the decision to pursue the question rather than to let it rest.

 

## A Name in the Database

 

The resolution of the Paul Fronczak case — to the extent that resolution has been achieved — rests on a simple material fact: enough people submitted their DNA to voluntary genealogical databases that the specific genetic patterns connecting the man raised as Paul Fronczak to the Rosenthal family, and later connecting Kevin Baty to the Fronczak case, were findable in those databases.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.