He had been Scott McKinley, in Newark foster care, before the Fronczaks adopted him. He had a birth name and a birth family that he had never known. The question — who is he? — was not philosophical or abstract. It was practical and urgent: what were the circumstances of his birth? Who were his parents? Why had he been abandoned in Newark with a black eye? Where was he born and when?
He began working with genealogical researchers and volunteers. The specific group that took up his case was DNA Detectives, a volunteer genealogy network that had developed expertise in using commercial DNA databases — the same kinds of databases that powered the consumer testing services that were becoming increasingly popular — to trace family connections that official records could not establish or that investigators had been unable to follow.
The process of genetic genealogy — using DNA matches in public databases to build family trees, identify probable relatives, and trace lineages — was not in 2013 and 2014 what it would become by 2019 and after. It was an emerging field, practiced by a small community of skilled volunteers and professionals who had recognized that the rapidly growing consumer DNA databases contained enough information to solve identity mysteries that conventional investigation had been unable to resolve. The DNA Detectives were among the pioneers of this approach.
The search took approximately two years.
## Jack and Jill Rosenthal
On June 3, 2015, DNA Detectives told Paul Fronczak the name he had been born with.
He was Jack Rosenthal. He had been born on October 27, 1963, in Atlantic City, New Jersey. He was not an only child: he had siblings, and among those siblings was a twin sister. Her name was Jill.
