Jack and Jill Rosenthal — the names are the same as the nursery rhyme, a coincidence that added an almost surreal layer to an already surreal case — had disappeared together. Both had vanished before their second birthdays, in the same period of the mid-1960s. Jack had been found, in a stroller in Newark, with a black eye, abandoned by persons unknown. Jill had not been found at all.
Their biological parents were Gilbert and Marie Rosenthal. By the time the DNA Detectives identified the connection and Paul Fronczak learned his birth name, both Gilbert and Marie were dead. They had died of cancer in the 1990s, more than two decades before the genetic investigation that would reveal what had happened to their children.
What relatives and former acquaintances of the Rosenthal family described, in interviews that emerged as the case attracted attention, was a household that was, by any reasonable accounting, dangerous for the children in it. Gilbert Rosenthal was described as a man with a violent streak, reportedly damaged by his experiences in the Korean War and suffering from what was then called shell shock and would later be recognized as post-traumatic stress disorder. Marie Rosenthal was described as a heavy alcoholic.
Former neighbors and relatives described a household in which the twins’ conditions were alarming. Susan Wohlert, a former babysitter who had been hired to care for the children, said that when she arrived she found them in an empty upstairs room, that one of them had a black eye, that the bedding was dirty, and that the room had a strong smell of urine. When the Rosenthals returned home the next morning — apparently having been drinking — they were furious to find her there.
