The British airman Alan Magee, a B-17 gunner who fell from his aircraft during a January 1943 raid on Saint-Nazaire, France, provides another documented case from the same war as Alkemade. Magee fell from approximately 22,000 feet when his parachute failed to open and crashed through the glass roof of the Saint-Nazaire railway station. The glass roof broke his fall sufficiently that he survived, though with severe injuries. He was taken prisoner and spent the remainder of the war as a POW.

The common thread across these cases is not that falling from great heights without parachutes is compatible with survival under ordinary conditions. It is that specific, unusual landing conditions — conditions that provide a more gradual deceleration than the sudden stop of hard-ground impact — have, on documented occasions, been the difference between survival and death. Each case required a specific combination of geography, physics, and circumstance that was not predictable in advance and that did not recur reliably.

The larger population of unsurvived falls from similar altitudes is vastly larger than the population of survived ones. For every Alkemade or Vulovic or Magee, there were thousands of airmen whose aircraft were destroyed or damaged at altitude and who died in the fall. The remarkable quality of the documented survival cases lies precisely in their rarity, and that rarity is itself a data point about how seldom the necessary combination of factors occurs.

—

## The Mathematics of Loss: Bomber Command Casualty Rates in Context

The specific losses of the March 24/25 Berlin raid — 72 aircraft from 811 dispatched — place within a larger numerical picture of Bomber Command’s campaign that merits attention, because the scale of losses in the strategic bombing campaign is not always conveyed by the narrative focus on individual missions and individual stories.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.