The postwar development of Bomber Command veterans’ associations, historical societies, and the broader infrastructure of Second World War aviation heritage — the air museums, the preserved aircraft, the memorial publications, the reunion events — created communities of memory that kept stories like Alkemade’s alive when the individuals who had lived them might otherwise have passed into obscurity. The RAF Museum’s interest in the story, evidenced by its published blog post, represents the institutional dimension of this preservation effort.

The television appearances — “Just Amazing!” and “I’ve Got A Secret” — represent the popular culture dimension: the appetite for the remarkable, the specific genre of the “you won’t believe what happened to me” narrative that has entertainment value independent of its historical significance. That Alkemade consented to these appearances suggests that he was not averse to the public dimension of his story; it also suggests that the story, by the 1980s, had a cultural currency that attracted television producers looking for the genuinely extraordinary.

—

## What the Fir Trees Did Not Know They Were Doing

There is a quality to the Alkemade case that resists the narrative frameworks most commonly applied to survival stories. The usual frameworks involve agency — the survivor’s will, the survivor’s skill, the survivor’s decisions. Alkemade’s survival involved a decision — the decision to exit the aircraft — but the actual survival was produced by factors entirely outside his agency: the specific location of the trees, the specific depth of the snow, the specific orientation of his unconscious body at impact.

He did not choose to land in young fir trees. He did not know they were there. He did not calculate the deceleration profile of a snow-covered hillside or select the optimal landing site from among the available options. He fell, unconscious, into a landscape that happened to be configured in a way that could absorb the energy of his fall. The trees did not know they were doing anything. The snow did not intend to save him.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.