The name she had been given by a kidnapper. The name she had been born with but never lived under. The question of which one was hers — if either, or both — was not one that DNA could answer.

—

## Sentencing

On August 15, 2016, Western Cape High Court Judge President John Hlophe sentenced Lavona Solomon to a total of fourteen years’ imprisonment, with four years suspended. The effective sentence was ten years’ direct imprisonment.

Judge Hlophe’s comments addressed the seriousness and premeditation of the offense. He found the crime too serious for anything other than custodial punishment. The defense had argued for leniency on the grounds that Lavona was a first-time offender with health problems. The prosecution had sought fifteen years.

Morne and Celeste Nurse, who had divorced after Zephany’s disappearance, both testified at sentencing about the impact the kidnapping had had on their lives. They described, to the court, that their relationship with their now-nineteen-year-old daughter was essentially non-existent.

The woman who had taken their daughter and raised her for seventeen years was now going to prison. Their daughter was alive, confirmed by DNA, legally identified — and largely a stranger.

—

## Lavona Solomon’s Defense and Its Implications

The question of whether the “Sylvia” account was truthful became a focus of ongoing commentary on the case. Lavona Solomon’s claim — that she was an unwitting participant, that she believed she was receiving a baby through an informal but legal adoption channel — contained internal inconsistencies that the prosecution and the judge found unpersuasive.

The inconsistencies included: the lack of any verifiable documentation for the alleged adoption arrangement; the absence of any evidence that a woman called Sylvia existed; the registration of Miché as her and Michael’s biological child in 2003, six years after the event, which required active deception rather than a passive acceptance of circumstances; and the trial testimony of Shireen Piet, who identified Lavona as the woman she had seen attempting to remove a baby from the ward on a prior visit.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.