DNA confirmed a biological fact. It could not undo seventeen years of emotional history. It could not make a stranger into a mother or a mother into a stranger. It could not resolve the name question, or the loyalty question, or the question of what a person owes to the family that raised her versus the family she was taken from.

Miché Solomon navigated these questions in public, with the scrutiny that comes from being the subject of a nationally and internationally followed case, while she was still a teenager and then a young adult. She navigated them without a roadmap. She made choices that were her own and that were not what everyone around her wanted.

She said she forgave. She said she still loves. She said the childhood was real, even though it was built on a crime. She said Zephany is the truth. She said both names are hers.

These are not easy positions. They are honest ones.

—

## The Question of What Lavona Solomon Wanted

Throughout the case, Lavona Solomon’s stated motivation — the desire for a child, the history of miscarriages, the profound want that drove her to the hospital ward in April 1997 — has been part of the record. The court rejected her specific account of how she came to have the baby, finding that she took the child herself. But the underlying motivation — a woman who desperately wanted a child — has been treated by commentators with varying degrees of sympathy.

The desire for a child is a human longing that has been understood and addressed across human history through legitimate means: biological parenthood when possible, adoption when not, various forms of social parenthood and community care. The crime Lavona Solomon committed — whatever its specific mechanics — was not the desire itself. It was the act of taking someone else’s child to satisfy that desire, without the consent of the child’s parents and without regard for the ongoing suffering that the act would cause.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.