The newspapers treated the case with an intensity that is difficult to overstate. Chicago’s major dailies assigned their top reporters. Correspondents came from newspapers across the country. The story was on the front page not just for days but for months — from the discovery of the body in May through the arrest in late May and early June, through the summer of legal proceedings, to the September sentencing.

Maurine Watkins, a reporter for the Chicago Tribune who was then at the beginning of her career, covered the trial. She would later go on to write the play that became the musical *Chicago*, and the Leopold and Loeb case clearly shaped her understanding of how crime, celebrity, and the press interacted in the city she was writing about.

The case also carried a heavy current of antisemitism. Leopold, Loeb, and Bobby Franks were all Jewish. Jacob Franks was a prominent member of Chicago’s German-Jewish community. The crime was quickly seized upon by elements of the press and by organizations like the Ku Klux Klan, which at that time was near its peak strength nationally, as evidence of some alleged moral failing of Jewish immigrants or Jewish wealth. This framing was ugly, pervasive, and largely absent from the institutional response to the case — the prosecution and defense conducted the proceeding without explicit antisemitic arguments — but it saturated the newspaper coverage and the public reaction in ways that the participants and observers could not entirely ignore.

State’s Attorney Robert Crowe, who would lead the prosecution, made public statements that characterized the defendants in terms that mixed contempt with something harder to categorize. He called them, in various statements, “cowardly perverts” and used language that left little ambiguity about his personal views of the two young men’s sexuality and character.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.