The families of both defendants were prominent enough to mobilize resources quickly. The Loeb family made the first contact, reaching out to Clarence Darrow.

—

## Clarence Darrow Takes the Case

Clarence Darrow was sixty-seven years old in the summer of 1924, and he had spent the preceding decades becoming the most famous defense attorney in the United States.

He had defended labor organizers, socialists, and anarchists. He had defended Black defendants in front of all-white juries in the American South. He had argued against the death penalty in courtrooms where the death penalty was simply assumed to be the appropriate outcome. He was not a man who took on easy cases. He was a man who took on the cases that clarified something important about the law and about justice.

He was also, by 1924, a committed and eloquent opponent of capital punishment. He had written about it, lectured about it, argued against it in courtroom after courtroom. He believed that execution was a relic — primitive, ineffective as a deterrent, and incompatible with what he understood to be a genuinely modern and rational system of justice.

The Leopold and Loeb case was, in its way, Darrow’s ideal case for making that argument. Here were two defendants whose guilt was not in question. No one was arguing that they hadn’t done it — they had confessed. Here were two defendants who had done something that many people, including most of the jurors available in Chicago, would regard as the most heinous possible crime. If Darrow could persuade a judge not to execute Leopold and Loeb, he would be making the argument against the death penalty in its hardest possible form.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.