The legal strategy he developed was striking in its simplicity and its audacity. Leopold and Loeb would plead guilty.

This was not the expected move. In a case of this magnitude, with this kind of public attention, the conventional approach would be to plead not guilty and mount a defense — perhaps an insanity defense, which the press had been anticipating. But Darrow understood what a jury trial would mean in Chicago in the summer of 1924. A jury of twelve ordinary citizens, drawn from a city that was reading about this case every day in newspapers that covered it with barely restrained outrage, would convict the defendants and very likely recommend death. The legal standard for insanity in Illinois at that time was extremely difficult to meet; a not guilty by reason of insanity verdict was not a realistic outcome.

By pleading guilty, Darrow bypassed the jury entirely. Under Illinois law at the time, a guilty plea in a capital case meant that the sentence would be determined by the judge alone. The judge was John Caverly, the Chief Justice of the Cook County Criminal Court, a man whose reputation suggested he was thoughtful, experienced, and not susceptible to the kind of mob pressure that might influence a jury.

The hearing on sentencing would become the trial in everything but name.

—

## The Psychiatric Testimony

One of the most significant aspects of the Leopold and Loeb proceedings — significant not just for this case but for the subsequent development of criminal law in the United States — was the extensive use of psychiatric testimony.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.