Darrow retained two principal psychiatric experts for the defense: William Alanson White, the superintendent of St. Elizabeth’s Hospital in Washington, D.C., and one of the most respected psychiatrists in the country, and Bernard Glueck of Sing Sing Prison in New York, who had extensive experience evaluating criminal defendants.

White and Glueck spent weeks examining both Leopold and Loeb in depth. Their testimony, which was lengthy and detailed, presented the two defendants not as evil but as damaged — as products of developmental histories that had produced specific, identifiable psychological conditions that the defense argued had contributed to the crime.

White’s analysis of Richard Loeb identified what he characterized as features consistent with paranoid personality development and a kind of arrested emotional development that had left Loeb fixated on fantasy — specifically the fantasy of crime as game — in a way that had dissociated him from ordinary moral reality. Loeb had not felt the killing, White suggested; it had been, to him, something between a chess move and a novel chapter.

White’s analysis of Leopold was different. Leopold showed features consistent with what White called a paranoid personality in a different configuration — a grandiosity, an extraordinary sense of his own specialness, an adoption of Nietzschean philosophy not as intellectual exercise but as personal permission. The world was divided into Supermen, who made their own rules, and ordinary people, who followed rules made by others. Leopold understood himself to belong to the first category.

Both analyses pointed, in different ways, toward the same conclusion: these were not normal young men who had made a horrific choice. They were young men whose psychological development — shaped, the psychiatrists argued, by specific factors in their upbringings — had produced the capacity to plan and execute a murder with detachment.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.