—

## Darrow’s Summation

The sentencing hearing stretched across the summer of 1924. Witnesses were called, evidence was presented, the psychiatric testimony was given and cross-examined at exhausting length. By August, the time had come for final arguments.

Clarence Darrow rose to give his summation on August 22, 1924.

He spoke for approximately twelve hours, spread across three days.

The summation that Darrow delivered in the Leopold and Loeb case is widely regarded as one of the greatest pieces of courtroom oratory in American legal history. It was not a speech that argued the defendants were innocent, or that what they had done was anything other than terrible. It was a speech that argued against the death penalty, in the most difficult case that could be imagined for making that argument, with a directness and an emotional power that left observers in the courtroom weeping — including, by multiple accounts, Judge Caverly.

Darrow argued several interlocking points. He argued that the defendants were young — nineteen and eighteen at the time of the crime — and that youth was itself a mitigating factor, that the courts and the philosophers and the moralists who had thought most carefully about punishment had consistently recognized youth as relevant. He argued that the defendants were themselves products of their upbringings, their environments, their biological inheritances — that the crime was not simply a matter of two boys choosing evil but of two boys whose capacity for ordinary human empathy had been distorted by forces they had not chosen and could not control.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.