He argued, most powerfully, that the death penalty was itself a form of barbarity — not justice, but revenge, dressed in the language of justice. He quoted poets and philosophers. He invoked the history of capital punishment across human societies. He argued that the history of civilization was, in part, a history of moving away from the impulse to destroy those who had transgressed, toward an understanding that destruction was not the same thing as justice.
He spoke about Bobby Franks. He acknowledged the horror of what had been done, the specific, irreparable harm. He did not minimize it. And he argued that adding two more deaths to the first would not undo that harm, would not serve any purpose that honest analysis could identify, and would leave society exactly as it had been, except with three people dead instead of one.
Robert Crowe’s rebuttal was forceful. He argued for the death penalty in terms that were explicit and unambiguous — that the defendants had shown no mercy to Bobby Franks, that they deserved none in return, that the law existed precisely to impose the ultimate consequence on those who had committed the ultimate crime. He characterized the psychiatric testimony as an elaborate excuse, a performance of science in the service of an outcome that science could not legitimately support.
The question was now entirely with Judge Caverly.
—
## The Sentence
On September 10, 1924, Judge John Caverly delivered his decision.
He began by reviewing the facts of the case — the planning, the execution, the disposal of the body, the ransom demand, the confessions. He acknowledged that the crime was of “singular atrocity” — a phrase that would be quoted for decades afterward. He made clear that he had given the question of appropriate punishment the most serious consideration of which he was capable.
