The glasses were the definitive proof of that. They were not a clue that clever detective work extracted from ambiguous circumstances. They were a clue that presented itself, almost helpfully, to anyone who cared to look at the culvert near Wolf Lake on the morning of May 22.

—

## The Defense Psychiatrists and What They Found

The psychiatric examination of Leopold and Loeb, conducted by William Alanson White and Bernard Glueck over weeks in the summer of 1924, was at that time an unusually thorough application of clinical psychiatry to a criminal case. Both White and Glueck were among the leading figures in American psychiatry, and their involvement lent the defense’s psychiatric case a credibility that the prosecution struggled to match.

White’s examination of Richard Loeb was extensive and produced a portrait of unusual specificity. Loeb’s childhood had been dominated by a governess — a woman who had controlled his environment, dictated his schedule, monitored his friendships, and left him with a stunted ability to form genuine emotional connections with other people. The governess had been demanding and isolating in ways that White argued had produced a profound developmental distortion: Loeb had learned to present a charming, socially adept surface while remaining emotionally disconnected beneath it. His obsession with crime fiction had provided a fantasy world that felt more real, in some sense, than the actual world around him.

White’s characterization of Leopold was different in emphasis. Leopold’s grandiosity — his conviction that he was a Superman, that ordinary moral rules did not apply to him — was itself a kind of defensive structure, White suggested, built over a more vulnerable personality that had experienced significant developmental disruption. The death of his mother at seventeen, the sexual abuse by a governess that Leopold disclosed to the defense team, the experience of being an odd, socially awkward boy in an environment that rewarded a different kind of social ease — all of these had contributed, White argued, to a personality structure that required the Superman framework as a kind of armor.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.