Darrow understood that the M’Naghten standard was essentially impossible to meet in this case. Both Leopold and Loeb had clearly known what they were doing was wrong — they had concealed it, they had created an alibi, they had disposed of evidence. The concealment itself demonstrated awareness of legal consequence. No psychiatric expert, however credentialed and persuasive, was going to persuade a jury that two men who had typed a ransom note, rehearsed a money drop, and thrown a typewriter into a lagoon did not know what they were doing was wrong.

The jury was also a problem entirely apart from the insanity question. Chicago in the summer of 1924, inflamed by weeks of newspaper coverage, with the specific grievance of a murdered fourteen-year-old boy from a prominent family, was not going to produce a jury that voted for anything other than death. Any jury selected from that pool, however carefully screened, would contain members who had formed opinions about the case before sitting down. The formal instructions requiring jurors to presume innocence would not, in practice, be enough to overcome that.

By pleading guilty, Darrow removed the jury. The sentence would be determined by one person, Judge Caverly, who was both legally and personally better positioned to hear a nuanced argument about punishment than twelve people drawn from a population that was reading about the case every morning in the newspaper.

The guilty plea also changed the structure of the proceeding. In a trial for not guilty defendants, the prosecution’s job is to establish the facts of the crime — to prove, to the jury’s satisfaction, that the defendants did what they are accused of doing. In a sentencing hearing for defendants who have already pleaded guilty, the facts of the crime are established. The proceeding is about something else: about what the appropriate consequences are for established facts. That is a more philosophical proceeding, one that invites the kind of argument Darrow was equipped to make and that State’s Attorney Crowe, whose strength was in establishing guilt, was less well-suited for.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.