Robert Crowe recognized this and objected to what he called Darrow’s manipulation of the proceeding. Crowe argued, in various public statements, that the psychiatric testimony was irrelevant, that the guilty plea had been designed to give Darrow the platform he wanted to argue against the death penalty in a case where the evidence of guilt was overwhelming, and that the judge was being used as a vehicle for a performance rather than a tribunal for a proceeding.

There was truth in this criticism. The hearing did have elements of performance — Darrow’s twelve-hour summation was a work of advocacy as much as of legal argument, designed to move as well as to persuade. But Crowe’s criticism also missed something: the performance was in service of a genuine and difficult legal and moral question, and the answer that Caverly ultimately gave was not an obviously wrong one.

—

## A Crime That Shaped a Genre

The Leopold and Loeb case stands at or near the beginning of what we now call the true crime genre — the nonfiction documentary examination of real crimes, presented in narrative form for a general audience.

This is not to say that accounts of real crimes did not exist before 1924. Crime reporting was as old as the newspaper, and the pamphlets and broadsides that described executions and confessions went back centuries further. But the Leopold and Loeb case, more than almost any other single event of its period, helped establish the template for the kind of extended, deeply reported, narratively constructed account of a real crime that would eventually become a defining genre of American nonfiction.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.