But the fact that those arguments were available to Leopold and Loeb in a form that was not equally available to defendants without similar resources is itself a fact about how the legal system works, and how it worked in 1924, and how it has continued to work since. The inequality is real. It is uncomfortable. It is part of what makes the case a persistent reference point in discussions about the relationship between wealth and justice.

The families of defendants who were executed in Illinois in the same general period — defendants who could not afford Clarence Darrow, who did not have prominent families able to mobilize resources quickly, who were not represented in the press as interesting psychological specimens but as simple threats to be eliminated — those families are not part of the Leopold and Loeb literature. Their cases are not famous. But their existence is part of the context in which the Leopold and Loeb case must be understood.

—

## The Case That Defined Its Decade

The 1920s in America is often characterized through its most iconic images: flappers, jazz, bootlegged whiskey, the first stirrings of mass consumer culture. But the decade also contained a persistent anxiety about what modern life was producing — about whether the affluence and freedom and educational ambition that the period celebrated were also producing a generation of young people without adequate moral grounding.

The Leopold and Loeb case was absorbed into that anxiety almost immediately. Here, the anxiety had a specific form: wealthy young men, educated at the best universities, with every material advantage, who had decided that their intelligence placed them beyond ordinary moral accountability. The philosophical framework — the Nietzschean Superman — gave the anxiety a name and a college address. If the universities were teaching this, and their students were taking it seriously enough to kill a fourteen-year-old boy, then something was wrong in the culture that the universities reflected and reproduced.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.