—

## The Alibi Construction in Detail

The alibi that Leopold and Loeb assembled for the afternoon of May 21, 1924, reflected their characteristic combination of careful planning and overconfidence. They had thought through what they would say. They had not thought through whether what they said could be independently verified.

Their account was this: they had been together that afternoon, driving around in Nathan Leopold’s car. They had stopped at some point and picked up two young women, whom they had spent time with. The women’s names were Edna and Mae — first names only, no last names provided, descriptions vague enough to fit many people. After spending time with the women, they had driven around further and eventually returned home.

This story had several structural weaknesses that became apparent the moment investigators began testing it. The absence of last names or specific addresses for the women made verification impossible — which was presumably intentional, since the women did not exist. But the impossibility of verifying the women’s existence was itself a flag: an alibi that cannot be corroborated in any direction is not an alibi, it is merely an assertion.

More critically, the alibi placed Leopold’s car in use during hours when it had been witnessed to be stationary. Sven Englund, the Leopold family’s chauffeur, was a problem that Leopold and Loeb had not adequately considered. Englund was not a hostile witness with a motive to cause trouble for the family he worked for. He was simply a man who had a specific, accurate memory of a specific day and who had no reason to adjust that memory in any direction.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.