Englund’s recollection was that the Leopold car had not left the garage during the period in question — from roughly one in the afternoon to ten in the evening. This was the period during which Leopold claimed he had been using the car. The discrepancy was fundamental. Either Leopold had been using the car or it had been in the garage; both could not be true.

The prescription slip that corroborated Englund’s account added a dated, documentary element to what might otherwise have been a question of one person’s word against another’s. A contemporaneous document placing Englund or a family member at a specific location at a specific time — a time inconsistent with the alibi story — was the kind of corroboration that investigators valued precisely because it was not generated by the investigation itself, could not have been fabricated in response to the investigation, and therefore represented genuine prior knowledge.

Leopold and Loeb had not anticipated Englund. This was partly an oversight and partly a reflection of a class-related blind spot: they had not thought carefully about what their employees knew, what records employees maintained, what employees’ specific memories might be. The chauffeur was part of the household’s functioning, not a person whose observations required accounting for in a criminal alibi. This failure of imagination — the failure to consider the perspective of someone whose daily work brought them into contact with physical evidence of the household’s activities — was part of what made the alibi collapse so quickly.

—

## The Typewriter Evidence Examined

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.