The typewriter evidence that helped expose Leopold and Loeb is worth examining in detail, because it illustrates a category of forensic evidence that has become more sophisticated but no less fundamental over the subsequent century: the individuation of a manufactured object.
The portable Underwood typewriter that Leopold had used to type the ransom note was, in itself, an ordinary object. Thousands of similar machines were in use in Chicago in 1924. The typeface they produced was standard. If the ransom note were the only document produced by that machine, it would have been extremely difficult to connect to any specific typewriter.
But Leopold had used the same machine for a different purpose: typing notes at meetings of his law school study group at the University of Chicago. Those notes had been circulated among the group’s members. Some of those members still had copies. The copies had been produced months or years before the murder, before anyone had any reason to pay attention to what typewriter had produced them.
When investigators obtained copies of those study group notes and compared them to the ransom note, they were comparing documents produced by the same machine across a span of time. The comparison was not simply of the font design — the standard Underwood typeface that all those machines produced — but of the specific variations that accumulated in this particular machine’s type elements over time and use. Individual keys wear differently. Some letters strike slightly off-center. Some produce impressions that are slightly lighter or heavier than others. These variations are distinctive to a specific machine, and they persist across documents produced by that machine.
