The match between the study group notes and the ransom note was the kind of evidence that typewriter examiners were beginning to systematize in the early 1920s — a nascent forensic discipline that the Leopold and Loeb case helped bring to public attention. The analysis required someone with the expertise to identify and document the specific characteristics shared between the two sets of documents, and the communication skills to explain those characteristics clearly enough that a judge or jury could understand why they were significant.

Leopold had made a specific error that made the typewriter evidence possible: he had used his own machine for both the innocent study group notes and the criminal ransom note. If he had used one typewriter for one purpose and a different machine for the other, the connection would not have existed. The error was, in retrospect, one of several places in the plan where the assumption of perfection had led to a failure of practical paranoia.

The physical machine, recovered from Jackson Park Lagoon after Leopold and Loeb had thrown it in with the keys removed, provided a different category of evidence: the physical match between the machine and the documents. The keys had been discarded separately, in a deliberate attempt to prevent the machine from being used for a comparison. But the machine had enough distinctive characteristics remaining — in the type element guides, in the specific wear patterns of the mechanical components — that identification remained possible.

The typewriter had been in the lagoon long enough that the evidence recovery was not trivial. But the investigators pursued it, the divers found it, and the evidence chain remained intact.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.