—

## The Legacy of Darrow’s Argument

Clarence Darrow’s summation in the Leopold and Loeb case occupies a specific place in the history of American legal advocacy — not as the best speech ever made in an American courtroom, a category too broad to rank with confidence, but as one of the most consequential in terms of the ideas it brought into the legal mainstream and the subsequent influence those ideas have had.

The argument against capital punishment that Darrow made in August 1924 was not new in its substance. Opponents of the death penalty had been making versions of these arguments for a century. What was new was the specific form of the argument in the specific context: the application of developmental and psychiatric analysis to the question of punishment, in a case where the defendants’ guilt was not disputed, where the crime was universally regarded as terrible, and where the conventional expectation was death.

Darrow argued that punishment must have a purpose, and that the only honest purposes available — deterrence, rehabilitation, incapacitation — were either unserved or better served by life imprisonment than by execution. Deterrence, he argued, was empirically unsupported: the existence of the death penalty had not prevented the crime. Rehabilitation was obviously unavailable to the executed. Incapacitation was equally served by a life sentence that could never be shortened.

What remained, Darrow argued, was revenge. And revenge was not, in his view, a legitimate purpose for a modern system of justice. It was an atavism — the remnant of an older, cruder understanding of what a legal system was for. A civilization that judged its own advancement by its distance from barbarism should recognize the death penalty as the most concentrated form of institutional barbarism available.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.