It was a plausible account. Leopold was indeed a serious ornithologist who had been to that area of Illinois many times in pursuit of birds. Wilson’s phalaropes did pass through the region during migration. The story could not be immediately dismissed.
But investigators arranged a test.
The jacket was obtained. The glasses were placed in the same outer pocket Leopold said he had been wearing them in. Men attempted to replicate the conditions of a fall — stumbling, tripping, lunging forward — in the manner that Leopold had described. The glasses did not fall out. They were tried again. And again. The hinges held the glasses in the pocket. No replication of the described fall could dislodge the glasses as Leopold said they had been dislodged.
The alibi was not impossible, but it was fragile. And investigators were simultaneously pulling at other threads.
—
## The Typewriter
The ransom note left by Leopold and Loeb was typed. This was understood to be a protective measure — handwriting analysis was a recognized forensic discipline by 1924, and a typed note could not be traced to an individual’s penmanship. The two had used what they believed was a secure typewriter, a portable Underwood that belonged to Leopold.
After Leopold’s arrest, prosecutors moved to find that typewriter. Leopold said he no longer had it. He had thrown it away, he claimed, along with some other items he no longer needed. This was partially true: before the investigation intensified, he and Loeb had disposed of the typewriter in Jackson Park Lagoon. The keys had been pried off first and thrown separately from a bridge. The body of the machine had gone in later, on May 25, four days after the murder. Investigators and divers later recovered the machine from the lagoon, around the first week of June.
