St. Leger withdrew from Fort Stanwix on August 22, 1777, two weeks after Oriskany. The fort held.

The Oneida who fought at Oriskany, including Han Yerry and Tyonajanegen and Cornelius, were part of the chain of events that kept Fort Stanwix in American hands, which contributed to the Saratoga campaign’s eventual outcome.

Samuel Kirkland and the Oneida Decision

The role of Samuel Kirkland in the Oneida’s decision to support the American cause is one of the most significant and most carefully examined questions in the scholarship of Oneida Revolutionary War history.

Kirkland had lived among the Oneida since the 1760s. He had learned their language, built relationships with their leaders, and created a sustained presence in their communities that gave him influence unusual for any outsider. His Presbyterian mission was a genuine enterprise — he believed in what he was doing — but his political commitments to the American cause inevitably shaped how he engaged with the Oneida leaders who were trying to decide what to do about the Revolution.

The specific debate about how much of the Oneida decision was Kirkland’s influence and how much was the Oneida’s own independent assessment of their interests is not fully resolvable from the available evidence. What is clear is that the Oneida leaders who made the decision — including Shenendoah, the principal sachem — were not passive recipients of missionary influence. They were political actors who had their own analysis of the situation and their own sense of where the Oneida’s interests lay.

The Oneida’s pro-American position was not simply “Kirkland told them to support the Americans.” It was a political decision made by people who had sustained relationships with both the British and American sides, who had watched what happened to other Indigenous communities under different colonial arrangements, and who had reached their own conclusion about which path offered the best prospects for Oneida survival and autonomy.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.