The Confederacy at the Breaking Point

To understand the significance of the Battle of Oriskany, it is necessary to understand the Haudenosaunee Confederacy — specifically, what the Revolution was doing to it.

The Haudenosaunee Confederacy — also known as the Iroquois, or the Six Nations — was one of the most sophisticated political systems in the pre-European Americas. The Confederacy had been established, according to Haudenosaunee tradition, through the Great Law of Peace — the Gayanashagowa — which united the original five nations (Mohawk, Oneida, Onondaga, Cayuga, and Seneca) and later the Tuscarora into a framework of shared governance and mutual obligation.

The Confederacy had endured for centuries through the principle of consensus: major decisions required the agreement of all nations, and the unanimous decision-making process prevented any single nation from imposing its will on the others. Wars between member nations were forbidden. The Grand Council of the Confederacy met at Onondaga, the central council fire, and addressed matters that affected all six nations together.

The American Revolution made this system impossible to sustain.

The revolution between the British and the American colonists presented the Haudenosaunee with a choice that their governance structure was not designed to resolve: which side to take in a war between two European-derived powers competing for the same territory. Each side had arguments for why the Haudenosaunee should support them. Each side had offers of alliance, of protection, of recognition. And the Haudenosaunee nations found themselves reaching different conclusions.

The Mohawk, most closely associated with the British through the longstanding alliance maintained by Sir William Johnson and through the specific Loyalist commitments of the Brant family, supported the British. The Seneca, Cayuga, and most of the Onondaga also supported the British, in part because the British had been the Confederacy’s principal treaty partner and in part because the British offered specific promises of protection for Indigenous territorial rights.

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
Share.